Politics: Justice in Mexico—the great deficit
Mexico's justice system faces a structural crisis of historic proportions, one that now carries direct geopolitical consequences. The US demand to extradite ten ruling-party politicians linked to criminal organizations has forced President Sheinbaum into an impossible dilemma: complying risks a severe internal political crisis; refusing risks economic, diplomatic, and security reprisals from the Trump administration. At the root of this predicament is a justice system so dysfunctional that it has long since forfeited the confidence of both its own citizens and foreign governments.
The scale of the problem is staggering. Of the 33.5 million crimes committed in Mexico in 2024, only 9.6% were reported, and formal investigations were opened in just 70.5% of those. The result is a "dark figure" — that is, unreported and uninvestigated crimes — of 93.2%, a rate that has not improved in thirteen years and that dwarfs comparable figures even in other Latin American countries. The primary reason victims do not report crimes is not fear, but resignation: 55% believe that reporting is a waste of time, and 77% cite either futility or distrust of authorities as their reason for staying silent.
The prosecutorial infrastructure is chronically underfunded and understaffed. Combined budgets for the FGR and 32 state offices have not reached their 2018 levels, and staffing has remained flat even as crime has increased. Each of the country's 3,731 operational prosecutorial agencies carries a caseload of roughly 573 formal investigations per year — approximately 2.6 per working day — making it structurally impossible to investigate, apprehend, and prosecute offenders within a standard workday. The predictable result: 99 out of every 100 crimes in Mexico go unpunished.
Two decades of reform — including the introduction of the oral adversarial system in 2008 and the conversion of attorney general's offices into nominally autonomous prosecutorial bodies — have failed to close this gap. Both transitions were incomplete: budgets were not increased, professional civil service systems were not implemented, political influence over prosecutors was not eliminated, and case management systems were not modernized. Pending caseloads have nearly doubled since 2020, rising from 1.52 to 2.64 million unresolved cases. Without sustained political will, meaningful institutional investment, and genuine accountability, Mexico's justice system will continue to be the weak link that fuels both domestic impunity and international friction.
Now read on...
Register to sample a report