Russian macro: 2020 outlook unchanged amid mixed statistics in April
Preliminary statistics for April released by Rosstat indicate that retail sales were sharply lower, both m-o-m and y-o-y, by 28.5% (not seasonally adjusted) and by 23.3%, respectively. The 4M20 tally fell by 2.8% y-o-y. A very deep contraction was generally expected, but the published figures seem to be not immune to certain questions. Food retail sales (including drinks) reportedly contracted by 15.2% m-o-m and by 9.3% y-o-y. The contraction in the non-food segment was much deeper (41.0% m-o-m and 36.7% y-o-y). Putting these numbers together with production statistics, particularly in the food segment, raises a question about the reliability of these numbers, as Rosstat also reported that food production in April was up 3.7% y-o-y. Whenever the ruble falls, as happened in April 2020, and imports contract significantly, the share of domestically produced and consumed goods goes up, but the consumption basket is taken from some previous year when the share of imported goods was higher. Therefore, structural shifts in the consumer market remain unnoticed for the time being. On top of that, some food sales may have been either miscalculated or simply underestimated due to significantly increased online food purchases and food delivery, which may not have been captured by Rosstat. Instead of the officially reported 9.3% y-o-y drop the decline in food retail could have been no more than 4% or so.
Based on April statistics, it looks as though GDP is going to contract by around 8% y-o-y in 2Q20 if to adjust food retail in the aforementioned way. A similar 8% y-o-y contraction can be expected in 3Q20 as well, while in 4Q20 the figure will be around 6%, potentially resulting in some 4-6% contraction in 2020 as a whole. This number does not differ much from our earlier projections.
* Given a reported deep decline in retail sales in April, the base effect of this decline will be felt during the entire 2020 and in early 2021. In 2020, retail sales may fall by 15-17% if to stick to the numbers published by the Rosstat in April. However, to adjust food retail as we have suggested, the decline of total retail sales may be limited by 8-10% in 2020.
* Food retail and consumption cannot in principle look like “V” as it is quite unlikely that the nation (not selected individuals) will suddenly start eating 15% more food next month or some other month later, i.e., to offset the 15% m-o-m drop in April. Hence an L-shaped recovery of food retail is more likely. That being said, the over-reported m-o-m drop in April’s food retail will have a much greater base effect on the full-year numbers than non-food retail. The non-food market may in principle resemble a kind of V-shaped performance.
* Performance in several sectors in April looked better compared to retail. Agricultural output increased by 3.1% y-o-y in April, which kept the 4M20 tally up 3.0% y-o-y. The output in the freight transportation sector fell by 3.1% m-o-m and by 7.2% y-o-y. Construction activity declined by 2.3% y-o-y in April, having posted 6.5% m-o-m growth (not seasonally adjusted). The 4M20 tally was up y-o-y by 0.1%.
* Inflation in Russia is seen to remain slightly above 3% by year-end and is not going to accelerate much in due course as demand will remain subdued, which may encourage the CBR to continue its series of rate cuts.
Now read on...
Register to sample a report